New cars are expensive. Always have been, most probably always will be. They also drop quickly in value, which is something you’ve no doubt read a lot about on this blog, especially lately when I’ve done my best to convince you of the merits of buying some truly great cars from 10-15 years ago rather than a new one. This comes from my conviction that they present an unbeatable monetary value, combined with a build quality and materials you simply don’t find anymore.
As I’ve come to realize though, in today’s world, those older cars offer something else. You could call it independence, or perhaps freedom. Because contrary to modern cars, those slightly older ones are not connected to the digital world. Why that is important is something we’ll look closer at today. But before going there, let’s look at the monetary side of buying a new car today.
Let’s assume you’ve decided to buy a new BMW 5-series, petrol, hybrid or electric. What you’ll quickly discover is that in spite of investing a large amount of cash (and let me just remind you that the same amount would buy you a Merc CLS, a Maserati Quattroporte AND a Jaguar XJ8 and still leave you with change), things that used to be standard for the price class aren’t anymore. Unless you pay extra you’ll be expected to adjust your seats manually, and those seats won’t be heated. The plastic surfaces are included though, and at least the windows are still electric. And of course you’ll get the big, wide infotainment screen stretching over a meaningful part of the dash.
Naturally you will want that screen to have its full functionality, but that’s not something BMW (or any other brand for that matter) have included in the base price, other than a basic set of function. For the rest there will be a separate price to pay, and a pretty hefty one, parts of which will also be in subscription format, such as your live navigation. There’s nothing wrong with that but of course, subscriptions are a brilliant way of making us humans forget the full price of things.
Now, let’s assume we’re a few years down the line, and that new or recent car has come out of warranty. One day as you push the starter button, the big screen doesn’t turn on. You’ll try to restart and in most cases, it will eventually light up, but in some cases it won’t. As anything electronic, a screen can break (unusual) or run into software issues (mostly the case) making it non-functional. A rather amusing example of a breaking screen is the 80-year old father of a friend of mine who bought a new car and got so frustrated with the infotainment screen after a few weeks that he smashed his fist through it.
What he and others have then discovered is that fixing the screen is mandatory in a new car, since it won’t be drivable without it. Doing so will be a challenge however, since most garages are precisely that and not computer shops. Fixing will thus in most cases mean replacing, which for one of those large, big modern screens usually comes in somewhere between CHF/EUR 4.000-8.000. Let’s just say that it’s something to be aware of.
Having said that, as noted initially, buying a new car has never been cheap and we’re still only talking about money. Also, most infotainment screens will hopefully not break anytime soon. It’s time therefore to move over to another, non-monetary cost a new car’s connectivity. And that’s precisely the fact that it is connected. The whole time.
Your modern, connected car accumulates data on everything youdo while you use it and relays that on to the manufacturer. The car will keep track of how fast you drive, how you accelerate, how you brake, and how often you drift sideways. Equally (and much like your phone), it will know what you’re talking to you passenger about, what music you like, and what podcasts you listen to.
That information will flow back to the BMW, VW or GM headquarters, who will then be happy to share it with some of their business partners. Don’t think they’re allowed to? Read the fine print. In some countries, your driving behavior as recorded by the car already influences your insurance premium. Drive smoothly and never above 70 km/h and you’ll pay less for the same car than if you emergency brake on every journey. You’ll never know for sure though, as no one will be capable, or at least willing, to explain the detail of your insurance bill.
A further dimension of the connectivity comes if your car is a BYD, Geely or Xiaomi, i.e. Chinese. Of course that also goes for Chinese manufacturers’ European sub-brands like Volvo or Polestar. In that case, the recorded information flows back to the company headquarters in China, where all companies are required by law to share information with the authorities on demand. And whereas the Politburo may not be interested by your braking pattern, they may well be so by where you go regularly, if for example you’re a military officer, or what kind of podcasts you listen to.
I listened to Xiaomi’s Chief Financial Officer on a podcast not too long ago. Xiaomi is of course the company that didn’t exist at the turn of the century and then built mobile phones until five years ago, when they decided to become a car company. Today they’ve become one of China’s largest EV manufacturers, and their 1500 hp top model, the SU07, set an EV record at the Nürburgring’s Nordschleife of 7 minutes 4 seconds last year, three seconds quicker than a Porsche Taycan Turbo GT.
When asked what he thought about European EV’s, the CFO said he thinks Europeans focus to much on the electric drivetrain and too little on the connectivity. “That’s really our focus in China”. I’m sure it is. It’s just that in other parts of the world, we’re a little less used to being surveyed by Big Brother as we go about our daily lives and our driving than the Chinese are.
That said, don’t think for one second there aren’t politicians in Brussels and other places who would just love to use the possibilities your car’s connectivity offers them to meddle in your life in a very Chinese way. Because if your car is connected, information can flow both ways. So if one day some bureaucrat decides that people really shouldn’t drive faster than 80 km/h, well, it’s not a big step to just limit your connected car’s top speed at a distance. Don’t feel like taking a break every two hours? What if your car forces you to?
A Swedish researcher at the country’s Defence Research Agency recently said he wouldn’t buy a Chinese car for precisly the reasons mentioned above, and that he thinks it’s important that Europe stops being naive about these kinds of matters. I can only agree, but we should also not be naive and think we’re protected from all of this as long as we drive older cars. Jacking up both insurance premia and fuel prices is perhaps the most obvious way for authorities to influence the future, but I’m sure they’ll find others. For that, politicians seem to be very reliable.
For now though, they haven’t, and we’re still able to enjoy our unconnected cars as freely and unrecorded as we want to. That’s good and if you ask me, something to cherish and realize that it may not last forever. I don’t see myself buying a new car ever again (over the 23 cars I’ve owned, I’ve actually only done it twice, long before the digital era), but if you’re about to, you should be aware of what you get yourself into.








































































































